Montauk Yacht Club Hotel, Montauk - Reviews, Room Options & Prices 2025

Book and save

up to 10%

compared to Booking.com

Key details

About the Hotel

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

The 4-star Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina blends historic elegance with modern comfort on Lake Montauk's waterfront, featuring 106 nautical-inspired rooms, private marina, and seawater pool surrounded by cushy lounges.

Waterfront Room Views

Waterview suites at Montauk Yacht Club feature king bedrooms, separate living rooms with queen sofa beds, and private balconies overlooking Lake Montauk or the courtyard. Each room includes air conditioning, a minibar, and premium resort amenities.

Local Waterfront Dining

Fresh, locally-sourced dishes transform into unique creations at waterfront eateries, complemented by poolside dining featuring traditional or spicy sriracha lobster rolls and smoked brisket.

Resort Recreation Options

The Pool Club offers swimming and lounging from May through September, while the Villa Lawn & Courtyard hosts corporate events. Guests access watersports including waterskiing, jet skiing, paddleboarding, and surfing.

Beach and Park Access

Gurney's Star Island provides complimentary shuttle service to a 2000-foot private beach, with six state parks and hiking trails nearby. The property sits 71.5 miles from Long Island MacArthur Airport.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Guest Room

Max:

4 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Balcony

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Villa

Max:

3 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

1 King Size Bed

Heating

Air conditioning

room details

Check Prices

Deluxe Room

Max:

2 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Sea view

Shower

Coffee machine

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

A guide to all available transportation options

City Center

Montauk 2.5 mi

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 69.7 mi

Tweed-New Haven (HVN) 107.4 mi

Facilities

Experience a variety of amenities at the boutique hotel, crafted to ensure your comfort and unforgettable moments

Free Wi-Fi

Free Wi-Fi in public areas

Parking

Paid parking

24-hour services

24-hour reception

24-hour security

Babysitting

General

No smoking on site
Free Wi-Fi in public areas
Parking
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
Pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
24-hour security
Baggage storage
Private beach
Allergy-free rooms
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness center
Water sports
Hiking
Cycling
Tennis court
Golf course
Fishing

Services

Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Dry cleaning
Welcome drink

Dining

Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Special diet menus

Business

Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Children's pool

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Seasonal indoor pool
Beach access
Spa & wellness center

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Mini-bar
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Ironing facilities

Bathroom

Bathtub
Free toiletries

Media

Flat-screen TV
AM/FM alarm clock

Room decor

Carpeted floor

Location

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

Map view

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, New York, United States of America, 11954

City landmarks

50 S Fairview Ave

Montauk Downs State Park

1.4 mi

W Lake Dr

Gosman's Dock

1.3 mi

Golf Course

Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course

1.4 mi

Parks

Shadmoor State Park

2.1 mi

Farm

Rita's Stable

1.7 mi

Farm

Deep Hollow Ranch

2.1 mi

67 South Essex Street

Saint Therese of Lisieux Church

2.3 mi

18 Ditch Plains Rd

Ditch Plains Beach

2.2 mi

Parks

Fort Pond Bay Park

2.5 mi

Museums

Second House Museum

2.8 mi

Parks

Camp Hero State Park

2.5 mi

Store

Sunset Surf Shack

2.5 mi

Parks

Kirk Park Beach

2.8 mi

Montauk

Lake Montauk

2.8 mi

Fort Pond Bay

2.7 mi

1898 Montauk Hwy

Camp Hero

3.0 mi

Lighthouse

Montauk Point Lighthouse

4.0 mi

Nearby

Marina

Star Island Yacht Club and Marina

1200 ft

Restaurants

Star Island Grill

400 ft

Star Island Rd

Westlake Fish House

2700 ft

352 W Lake Dr

Swallow East Restaurant

1.2 mi

474 W Lake Dr

Grey Lady

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr

Tiny Harbor Asian Cafe

4900 ft

440 W Lake Dr Unit B

The Dock

1.1 mi

482 West Lake Dr

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience.

84%

enjoyed the hotel and would happily stay again

8.4/10

Great

Rooms

8.0

Location

8.4

Service

7.6

Dining

7.4

3.5/5 based on 80 reviews

#25 of 39 hotels in Montauk based on Tripadvisor

Glenn

United States of America, February 2025

5.6/10

My stay at the Montauk Yacht Club was a mix of enjoyable moments and frustrating experiences. The picturesque marina views and the comfortable room exceeded my expectations, but the staff's attentiveness was overshadowed by issues with the dim lighting and cramped spaces throughout the hotel. While I relished the beautiful location, I felt that the renovations left much to be desired, especially concerning dining arrangements and overall atmosphere. 😕🌅

Rooms

6.0

The room was clean and spacious, but the beds felt cozy and a bit too small for a comfortable sleep.

Service

5.0

While the staff was friendly, the reception area was less helpful than I had hoped when navigating the hotel.

Location

7.0

The location is fantastic with beautiful marina views, but the arrangement of furniture made some areas feel overcrowded.

Dining

5.0

The dining experience was a letdown, as the food was tasty but overpriced, not matching the expectations set by the ambiance.

Facilities

6.0

Facilities like the pool were beautiful, but the narrow hallways made getting around inconvenient, detracting from the overall experience.

Hank

United States of America, December 2024

6.2/10

I had an lovely stay at Montauk Yacht Club, where the scenic marina views, comfortable rooms, and really good service made for a luxurious experience. The beautiful grounds, including pools and a private beach, added to the tranquility. However, I felt that the food lacked flavor and could be improved. Overall, I left feeling relaxed and wanting to return soon.

Rooms

10.0

My room was huge, beautifully renovated, and clean, with a spacious layout. I loved the large balcony overlooking the marina (a perfect spot for morning coffee).

Service

10.0

The staff went above and beyond to meet my needs, from the dock staff to the restaurant team. Tim's warm welcome and later boat ride arrangement were especially commendable.

Location

10.0

Located right on the marina, the hotel provided stunning views and a peaceful atmosphere. It was also close to various recreational activities, enhancing my stay.

Dining

8.0

While the restaurant Showfish served fresh daily catches, the food was somewhat bland based on my expectations for such a premium setting. I felt there were better dining options nearby.

Facilities

10.0

The facilities were impressive, with pools, workout areas, and plenty of activities like kayaking and paddleboarding. Housekeeping ensured everything was well-stocked and clean during my visit.

John

United States of America, November 2024

5.2/10

My stay at Montauk Yacht Club was a blend of luxury and charm, although some noisy disturbances dampened the experience. From being greeted with champagne to enjoying the heated pool, it truly was a good retreat. However, noise from nearby rooms and a false fire alarm early one morning detracted from my overall rest and relaxation.

Rooms

8.0

The rooms were beautifully renovated, spacious, and incredibly comfortable, featuring high-quality bed linens. I particularly loved my view of the marina from the mini deck, though I did notice that the walls were quite thin, which led to some nighttime disturbances.

Service

7.0

The staff were incredibly friendly and eager to help, making me feel right at home. However, the front desk could be slow to respond during busy times, which was frustrating when I needed assistance.

Location

8.0

The location is beautiful, right next to the marina, offering stunning views and a tranquil atmosphere. Still, the hotel felt a bit crowded at times, especially around the pool area.

Dining

7.0

Dining at Showfish was a highlight, as the food was delicious and made use of fresh, local ingredients. I did encounter some inconsistency, particularly with breakfast options that didn’t meet expectations.

Facilities

7.0

I enjoyed the heated outdoor pool and excellent poolside service. Although there were plenty of recreational activities available, I had hoped for a less crowded experience during my visit.

Jeffrey

United States of America, November 2024

7.0/10

My stay at Montauk Yacht Club was really enjoyable overall, with stunning marina views and a sweet, welcoming atmosphere. The highlight for me was the delicious food at Showfish, though some aspects like the noise from other guests were a bit of a downside. Still, the beautiful grounds and the friendly staff made for a lovely experience.

Rooms

8.0

I found the rooms to be new and comfortable, with great bed linens, but they are on the small side. The waterfront view from my balcony was really nice, making it a cozy spot to relax.

Service

9.0

The staff were super friendly and attentive, always eager to help. They made my husband’s birthday extra special with thoughtful touches upon our arrival.

Location

9.0

This place has an amazing location with beautiful scenery and easy access to local spots. Plus, having the beach nearby was definitely a plus, although the tiny beach was a little rough on the sand.

Dining

8.0

Dining at Showfish was a delight! I loved my dinner choices, especially the seared scallops, even if I had a hiccup with the breakfast muffin selection earlier in the stay.

Facilities

7.0

I appreciated the relaxing ambiance and the variety of recreational activities available, though my rain-soaked trip limited some options outdoors. The pool area looked inviting too.

Francis

United States of America, October 2024

5.4/10

I had a wonderful experience at the Montauk Yacht Club, with stunning ocean views and comfortable accommodations. The resort's recent remodel combined luxury with the charming Montauk vibe, which I really appreciated. However, I did encounter some issues, like inconsistent service at times and a notable problem with noise from nearby rooms. Overall, it felt like a luxurious escape with a few hiccups that could be improved.

Rooms

8.0

My room was bright, spacious, and very comfortable, with a lovely ocean view from the balcony. However, I did notice some noise issues from adjacent rooms.

Service

7.0

Most of the staff were attentive and friendly, especially at the restaurant where the food was amazing. Yet, I had some issues with service being inconsistent, particularly poolside.

Location

8.0

The resort is nestled beautifully by the marina, allowing for serene views and easy beach access. I really enjoyed being close to local attractions but found some aspects of the overall welcome area could be enhanced.

Dining

9.0

The dining experience at Ocean Club was exquisite, with delicious dishes and great service. I did notice that while the food quality was high, prices were quite steep, which might be expected at a resort.

Facilities

7.0

The amenities were plentiful, from the beautiful pool to the private beach, but I was disappointed with the inconsistent enforcement of safety policies during my stay, particularly in the gift shop.